--- title: "Honest Song Feedback — Not Friends-and-Family Praise | Song Refiners" description: "Submit one song and get a clear, no-sugar-coating read on what's working, what's not, and exactly what to fix. Your first review is free." lang: en json-ld: | [ { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "Organization", "name": "Song Refiners", "alternateName": "SongRefiners", "url": "https://songrefiners.com", "logo": "https://songrefiners.com/images/song-refiners-og.png", "description": "Song Refiners blends cutting-edge tech with human expertise to help songwriters strengthen craft, melody, and emotional impact. It ALL Starts With Your Song!", "founder": { "@type": "Person", "name": "Keith Mohr", "description": "30+ year music industry veteran, founder of Nashville Rising Song and AI Rising Song" }, "sameAs": [ "https://www.facebook.com/songrefiners", "https://www.instagram.com/songrefiners", "https://x.com/SongRefiners", "https://www.youtube.com/@songrefiners", "https://www.tiktok.com/@songrefiners", "https://www.airisingsong.com", "https://www.nashvillesongpitcher.com" ], "contactPoint": { "@type": "ContactPoint", "contactType": "customer service", "email": "info@songrefiners.com" } }, { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "WebSite", "name": "Song Refiners", "url": "https://songrefiners.com" }, { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "BreadcrumbList", "itemListElement": [ { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 1, "name": "Home", "item": "https://songrefiners.com/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 2, "name": "Are You Serious", "item": "https://songrefiners.com/are-you-serious" } ] }, { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "FAQPage", "mainEntity": [ { "@type": "Question", "name": "What kind of feedback will I get?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Honest evaluation of where your song stands, a clear breakdown of strengths and weak spots, and actionable rewrite guidance you can use right away." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Who is Song Refiners for?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Writers who are serious about getting better — finishing songs, preparing to pitch, record, release, or revise, and who want more than 'sounds good' from friends and family." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Is the first review really free?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Yes. Every new songwriter receives a free Red Carpet Review automatically when they sign up. No credit card required." } } ] } ] --- [Visit Website](https://www.songrefiners.com)![Song Refiners logo](/assets/song-refiners-splash-Bplmj8vo.png) Real Feedback. Real Direction. # Honest feedback on your song — not the praise your friends keep giving you. Submit one song and get a clear, no-sugar-coating read on what's working, what's not, and exactly what to fix next — so you stop guessing and start rewriting with purpose. Your first review is free, no credit card. [Get My First Review Free](/auth?signup=true&quicktaste=true) [See How It Works](#how-it-works) Built for songwriters who want real feedback—not empty praise. Trusted by 1800+ songwriters · Nashville-based · First review free ## Why Song Refiners Most songwriters don't need more opinions. They need a clear read on where the song stands and what to do next. Song Refiners is designed to help writers improve songs through focused critique and revision insight—actionable feedback that helps you move forward faster. Know what's landing and what's weak Get specific feedback on lyrics, melody, hook, structure, and commercial potential See what to rewrite instead of wondering why the song is not connecting Improve your next draft with a clearer target ## See Exactly Where You Stand This is what a real review looks like — no sugar-coating, no cheerleading. ![Example Song Refiners review showing scores and detailed feedback for Burnin' Midnight Oil](/__l5e/assets-v1/e396fa0d-b599-4f88-a6f8-3fe214d83201/burnin-midnight-oil-example.png) [See Full Example Review](https://www.songrefiners.com/example-review) ## Who It's For Writers who care enough to hear the truth. If you want to know whether your song is strong, average, or still missing the mark, this is for you. - Writers finishing songs and wondering if they're ready - Songwriters preparing to pitch, record, release, or revise - Artists who want more than "sounds good" from friends and family - Writers who are serious about getting better ## Who It's Not For If you only want compliments, Song Refiners is probably not the right fit. The goal is clarity, growth, and stronger songs—not polite feedback that leaves you in the same place. - Not for writers looking for a pat on the back - Not for people who never plan to revise - Not for anyone who would rather guess than know ## What You Get Detailed, personalized feedback and concrete next steps. Song Refiners is built around helping writers understand their current level and improve revisions over time—a sharper promise than generic feedback alone. Honest evaluation of where your song stands Clear breakdown of strengths and weak spots Actionable rewrite guidance you can use right away Feedback that helps you improve this song and the next one ## How It Works Three simple steps. No guesswork. 01 ### Submit your song Send your lyrics, audio, or both, depending on the review option you choose. 02 ### Get a straight read Song Refiners evaluates what is working, what is weak, and where the song currently stands. 03 ### Rewrite smarter Use the feedback to strengthen the hook, lyric, melody, structure, or overall impact of the song. ## What Songwriters Are Saying Real feedback from real songwriters who've been through the process. Thank you again for developing this wonderful system. It just keeps getting better and better! My newest song hit 99 and I couldn't have gotten it this far in only a few days without Song Refiners! Dan White Great review, very encouraging!!! I love digging into the coaching questions, and I'm learning so much about songwriting. Finding Song Refiners online has changed my life since I made the choice to get better not bitter! Robin Godinez This incredibly detailed review of my song has opened my eyes to a whole new way of understanding and thinking about making music going forward. I think it will help me to become a better songwriter and to connect with my music in a more meaningful way. Ryan Allen [Read all reviews from our songwriters](/user-reviews) Built by Keith Mohr , a Nashville-based songwriter and producer with decades inside the industry — every review reflects how working pros actually critique songs. You keep 100% ownership of your song. Always. ## You Don't Need More Encouragement. You Need Clarity. Song Refiners helps you stop second-guessing and start making better songwriting decisions with real feedback and real direction. No Empty Praise Honest Critique Clear Direction Real Growth ## Your First Review Is Free Find out where your song stands before you pitch it, record it, or spend another dime on it. [🎉 You get this free on signup Red Carpet Review Automatically included — no credit card, no decision needed. Headline, overall score, and 1–2 sentences per section. Your first review is automatically included when you sign up — just submit your song. Get Your Free Review ](/auth?signup=true&quicktaste=true) After your free review, deeper feedback is available when you're ready Standard Review · 1 Credit All 7 scored categories, timestamped feedback, coaching questions, and actionable next steps. Earn your first one free by rating & commenting on your Red Carpet Review. Most Detailed Deep Dive · 3 Credits 3 strengths and 3 fixes in every section instead of 1 and 1 — the full picture of your song's strengths and gaps. - 8–10 section-level insights - Enhanced coaching notes - Priority processing Credits are $1 each , with discounts on quantity packs — full pricing shown after your free review. No subscription required. ## Common Questions Quick answers before you submit your first song. ### Is the first review really free? ### What do I need to submit? ### How long until I get my review back? ### What genres do you cover? ### Will you take ownership of my song? ### Is this just AI feedback? ## Ready to Know Where Your Song Really Stands ? If you're serious about writing better songs, get feedback that tells you what's working, what needs help, and what to do next. [Get My First Review Free](/auth?signup=true&quicktaste=true) No credit card · First review free · Results in minutes!