Your First Review Is Free. Then $1 a Song.
Four tiers of review, from your free first review to our deepest member-only analysis. Pick what fits your song.
Credits are simple: 1 credit = $1. Members get 50 credits a month for $29.99, which works out to about $0.60 a review.
Red Carpet Review
One time · no credit card · starts right away, ready in about the length of your song
- Full scores across all 6 categories + Overall
- Section-by-section feedback + wrap-up
- Revealed as you read, so nothing gets skipped
Standard
Ready in about 1 hour · runs in our regular queue
- Full scored review
- 6 scored categories + Overall Score: Title, Top Line, Lyrics, Arrangement, Production, Commercial Potential
- 1 strength + 1 fix per section, each fix tagged by severity (12 points)
- Coaching + next steps
Deep Dive
Starts right away · ready in about the length of your song
- 3 strengths + 3 fixes per section (36 points) — 3× the detail of Standard
- Alchemy section included
- Timestamped feedback + coaching
- Live text chat with your reviewer — first 10 messages free
Double Fire
Refinery members only
Starts right away · ready in about the length of your song
- Everything in Deep Dive
- Showcase — sync licensing & pitch opportunities on every review
- 5+ strengths and 5+ fixes per section (60+ points) — the deepest read we do
- Live text chat with your reviewer — first 10 messages free
Credits also run The Generator and The Catalyst, built on the newest Suno V6. Set your own song length, and download every take with no download limits and no Suno account needed.
How much detail you actually get
Every section comes back as What's Working and What Needs Work, with each issue marked Critical, Needs Attention or Polish so you know what to fix first.
Refinery — $29.99/mo
50 credits a month. Month to month, cancel anytime. No contract.
Score 90+ and you're eligible for Updraft, where A&R, publishers, and sync supervisors listen and message you directly. 90+ songs also get considered for airplay on HitSongsRadio.com. You keep 100% ownership either way.
Members also get our deepest review tier (Double Fire) on every song, plus a Showcase with AI-researched sync licensing, industry contacts, and playlist matches included on every review — no score threshold.
Works out to about $0.60 a review. Buying credits one at a time costs more per review than membership does.
- 50 credits per month, deposited on your anniversary date
- Double Fire reviews on every submission — 5+ strengths and 5+ fixes in every section, 60+ named points
- Alchemy section — syllable counts, rhyme maps, melody contour, hook math, ear-worm score
- Showcase included on every review — no score threshold
- Priority processing on every review at just 1 credit
- Weekly meetups with Keith — Tuesdays at 7PM CT
- My Pitches — your professional pitch page with your own continuous-play radio station
- HitSongsRadio.com airplay — 90+ scoring songs are eligible for rotation
- Updraft: Songs 90+ by Refinery Members are eligible for addition to our private industry pitch portal
- Frequent Refiner Rewards — earn credits and perks as you submit
- The 90 Club & Power Refiners leaderboards
New here? Your first review is free.
Sign up free, no credit card. Claim your one-time Red Carpet Review, jump straight to a Deep Dive, or upgrade to a Refinery membership anytime from inside your account. Want the detail first? See what our song critique service includes and how we score all 6 categories plus the Overall score.
Prefer a human ear?
Get a personal review from Keith Mohr
30+ years in the Nashville music industry. Keith listens to your song, reads your lyrics and backstory, and writes you an honest, conversational letter. One time $50, delivered within 24-48 hours.
Request a human review