What Songwriters Are Saying
Unedited feedback from real songwriters who've put their songs through the refinery.
“I don't like giving perfect scores but this review is damn close. The things I wanted the reviewer to pick up un were all mentioned in the review. Most of the suggestions from the AI were good ones!”
“With Song Refiners coaching, I feel like this song is much, much stronger. Thank you!”
“I’m really grateful for this constructive criticism because it is just that constructive. It’s exactly what I need as I learn how to be a songwriter.”
“I appreciate your sticking with me. I do think your observations and promptings are valuable.”
“WHEW! Thank you Song Refiners! It's a much better song now. I felt I had a good idea for this song, but as usual, sitting on my shelf. Prior to SR. It was somewhat completed but lacking luster. It wasn't popping. I needed help in going about it. The lyrics took a BIG turn. I admit, I was a little reluctant but the end result is much better than I could ever have hoped for. At this point in my Song Writing studies. I really don't know what I would do without songrefiners.com. Seriously.”
“This song was transformed into a totally new song and I love it! Thank you!”
“I really respect the context of this review. It touched many based and was helpful for my next steps. The metrics it used are poignant for the success of this song, especially from my independent writing potential. I'm going to now revise with the suggested edits and come back for another review. Thanks.!”
“I appreciate the honesty in the review and accept the suggestions. I will immplement them and come back to see how much I have improved it.”
“Great feedback and insight on some things I hadn’t considered in writing!”
“I applaud your brutally honest critique. I will send a couple other songs for your review in the coming days. Thank you!”
“Very good insight on my music and helps break it down so I really understand what needs tweaking thanks a lot!! I'm really feeling the feed back you'll give , its very helpful and not feel judged I really like this thanks!!”
“It actually was a very insightful and helpful review and I'd recommend it for feed back.”
“I really appreciate any & all feedback on my songs. It's very helpful, as it helps me to know where I need to make improvements & change the song around in order to be successful. Thank you!!”
“I should have sent the song to you before recording it.”
“I really love the suggestions the reviewer gives. It's really quite helpful. While I don't do EVERYTHING it suggests, because not all of it something that I feel benefits the project, a lot of what it suggests not only works, but really enhances the end result. The thing I really like about it, is that it "knows" me. It actually knows I am working on a concept album. I have told it the basics of the story, and it actually understands the story from the lyrics I've written and has given STORY suggestions. It detected the flow, it even detected the musical motif that I'm using throughout the album. It's almost scary! haha. The thing that is REALLY cool, is on my previous album, it understood that that album was more of a Christian Rock album, it also knows this album is a completely different genre, is not Christian (though it has a Christian Worldview).”
“It was refreshing to see an actual score of the song i wrote!”
“I was blown away!!!!”
“Dead on and great suggestions!!!”
“Just to see what this was like, I uploaded a song which had already had a professional Nashville song coach review. This resource gave me the same input he did, plus more, and I didn't have to wait for a week and an appointment! Great job!”
“Was actually impressed that your llm was trained to analyze in this fashion. I have trained a few and this was good work.”
“I am extremely satisfied and somewhat surprised at the depth of the review! I’m going to use the recommendations to improve my song.”
“These reviewers seem so personal and real. As a techie, I really appreciate that. Thanks for the "heavy lifting" (they say that a lot!) of making the chat with the reviewers and the actual reviews themselves personal, on point, and direct, but never mean or intimidating. It makes me desire to keep reviewing and making my songs climb the 90's ladder.”
“Best review ever!!”
“An amazing breakdown of the lyrics, the strong lines and what to do about the weaker ones. I'll be back with a revision soon! 😊”
“This is the second review I've gotten, and they have both been very helpful and valuable. Sometimes there are things you just can't see because you are too close to the work. This process provides the objective look that helps you refine and improve.”